Blog Layout

State Land Use Commission takes up Hawaii County’s STVR law

Taylor Rodamer • July 30, 2020
The question of whether Hawaii County can prohibit short-term vacation rentals on land classified as agriculture is now in the hands of the state Land Use Commission.

Both the county and a group of 20 Kailua-Kona, Waimea and Captain Cook landowners have asked the LUC for a declaratory ruling. The commission considered the issue Thursday, then postponed the hearing until Aug. 12.

The ruling will have far-reaching ramifications. Some 1.2 million acres on Hawaii Island — almost half of the land mass — is classified as agriculture.

State law requires houses to be farm dwellings and have a connection to agriculture if they’re built on land classified under the state system as being in the agricultural district. The farm dwelling requirement took effect June 4, 1976, leading the county Planning Department to allow nonconforming use permits only for STVRs on lots created before that date.

Farm dwellings are defined in state law as single-family dwellings located on and used in connection with a farm or where agricultural activity provides income to the family occupying the dwelling.

“Farm dwellings may not be used as short-term vacation rentals,” Deputy Corporation Counsel John Mukai said. “Farm dwellings can only be used in connection with agricultural use and not for residential use.”

The property owners disagree.

“Contrary to the County’s understanding of Chapter 205, the laws governing the State Agricultural District do not regulate the length of rental agreements,” said Cal Chipchase, attorney for the property owners in filings. “Cutting through the doubletalk, County Ordinance No. 2018-114 allows anyone to rent a “farm dwelling” located in the State Agricultural District for residential or vacation purposes as long as the lease is for 31 days or more.”

Chipchase points to testimony by county Planning Director Michael Yee that the county considers buildings built on agricultural land to be farm dwellings as long as the owner signs a farm dwelling agreement. There is little, if any, enforcement afterward to see if there is indeed any farming going on.

Under grilling from two commissioners, Yee on Thursday tried to clarify the position. A farm dwelling, he said, is a permitted use on agricultural land, while an STVR is not.

If someone signed a farm dwelling agreement and then doesn’t farm, “they’d be in violation and we may not find out five years down the road, 10 years down the road,” but farm dwellings are still a permitted use, Yee said.

An STVR, on the other hand, isn’t a permitted use, Yee said, “just as we wouldn’t necessarily allow a junkyard on that land.”

Mary Alice Evans, director of the state Office of Planning, agreed with the county’s interpretation of the law.

“Even if the county has not been effective in its enforcement of HRS § 205-4.5(a)(4), i.e., to identify and prosecute owners/operators of farm dwellings operating as STVRs, the law has always required that a farm dwelling be used in connection with a farm, and not for just residential uses or STVR uses,” Evans said in a July 17 filing. “The inability of the county to enforce these statutory provisions does not render the law invalid nor does it render the violators of the law in compliance or not subject to the law. … Accordingly, it is incumbent on the Commission to protect the Agricultural District by upholding the purpose and intent of the State Land Use Law by declaring that a STVR is not a permitted use of a farm dwelling in the Agricultural District.”

Share

February 24, 2022
Here’s the scoop on what’s tax deductible when buying a house. 
February 24, 2022
Don’t rouse the IRS or pay more taxes than necessary — know the score to avoid common tax mistakes.
January 20, 2022
Home buyers who do mortgage loan shopping can avoid leaving money on the table.
January 20, 2022
Stream Season 2 on Hulu, Youtube, or Facebook
December 21, 2021
Not all home improvements are created equal. These will reward you the most when it comes time to sell.
October 26, 2021
Did you hear the one about the dog who wrote a love letter? Not to his owner, but to a home seller. Well, actually the dog’s owner wrote the letter in Buddy’s voice, describing how wag-worthy the house was and how much he craved a game of fetch in the backyard. Doggie ghostwriting, which happened IRL, is just one example of how home buyers are using creativity to try to get their offer accepted. It sounds harmless enough. But buyer letters to home sellers can unintentionally create Fair Housing Act discrimination and risks for buyers, sellers, and their agents. How Love Letters to Home Sellers Work “A love letter is any communication from the buyer to the seller where the buyer is trying to set themselves apart,” says Deanne Rymarowicz, associate counsel at the National Association of REALTORS®. “ It could be an email, a Facebook post, a photo. Some buyers send elaborate packages with videos and letters. The communication has the intent of ‘pick me, and here’s why.’” Buyers who write the letters typically send them to the listing agents, along with their offers, says Paul Knighton, CEO and cofounder of MORE Realty in Tigard, Ore. “They ask, ‘Would you please pass this along to the sellers?’ They’re trying to do what they can to get their offer accepted, especially in a competitive market.” Letters Can Risk Violating Fair Housing Act While these love letters may seem harmless enough, they can create a problem if buyers accidentally reveal information in one or more of the seven areas protected by the Fair Housing Act, Rymarowicz explains. Those areas are race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national origin. “Buyers could say something like, ‘this is down the street from our temple,’ or ‘the hallways are wide enough to accommodate my wheelchair.’ Anything that provides personal information related to one of the prohibited bases for discrimination could result in a violation if a seller makes a decision based on that information.” Do Love Letters to Home Sellers Work? In addition to creating potential risk, love letters to sellers aren’t all that effective, Knighton says. A case in point: Several years ago, one of his clients got 14 offers overnight, ranging from $219,000 to $250,000. “A person who offered $225,000 wanted to send a love letter. I said to him, ‘You’re writing an offer that’s $25,000 under the highest offer. A letter’s not going to help.’ He wrote it anyway, but the seller didn’t even read it and took the higher offer. The offer needs to stand on its own.” Beyond ignoring the letters, some sellers may be completely turned off, Rymarowicz says. “They may think, ‘This is a financial transaction.’” Even the circumstances can suggest Fair House Act discrimination, she explains. Say that an offer with a love letter got the house but was less attractive than an offer without a letter. “If the losing buyer doesn’t share characteristics of the seller and the winning buyer does, you could potentially have a situation. If sellers accept love letters, it’s more important that they document the basis of their decision when selecting a winning offer.” Tips to Avoid Violating the Fair Housing Act Here are five tips to avoid risk of violating the Fair Housing Act: 1. Keep the contract in mind: Knighton says real estate pros at his firm talk to buyers and sellers about contract boundaries. “We say, 'Please don’t communicate with the other party, because we are in contract negotiations and need to manage time frames.'” 2. Focus on objective information: Find ways to differentiate yourself on objective terms. And talk to the agent about how to improve the substance of your offer, Rymarowicz advises. “Can you make a larger earnest money deposit? Can you give them a longer closing date?” 3. Proceed with caution: The NAR discourages buyer letters to home sellers and advises caution, according to Rymarowicz. 4. Talk to your agent: Don’t be surprised if your real estate agent brings up the subject. “If you’re the seller, the listing agent may talk to you about the potential for Fair Housing violations. They may ask if you want to accept the risks,” Rymarowicz says. If the agent doesn’t raise the subject of buyer letters, the buyer or seller can do so. 5. Know your state law: Oregon passed a law governing how letters to home sellers are used. “Effective January 2022, a seller’s agent must reject any communication from a buyer other than customary documents,” Knighton says. Even if a buyer letter to a seller focuses on the property and not the buyer, there’s little to be gained, Knighton says. “There’s risk, but the reward isn’t there. Instead, focus on writing a really strong offer. That’s what has to stand out.”
By HouseLogic September 22, 2021
See firsthand what first-timers face, and how relying on the expertise of a REALTOR®, a member of the National Association of REALTORS®, helps them prep for the unexpected and make sure this milestone decision is made with confidence. Watch Here ->
By HouseLogic September 22, 2021
Oh, let’s just admit it, shall we? Browsing for homes online is a window shopper’s Shangri-La. The elegantly decorated rooms, the sculpted gardens, the colorful front doors that just pop with those “come hither” hues. Browser beware, though: Those listings may be seductive, but they might not be giving you the complete picture. That perfect split-level ranch? Might be too close to a loud, traffic-choked street. That handsome colonial with the light-filled photos? Might be hiding some super icky plumbing problems. That attractively priced condo? Miiiight not actually be for sale. Imagine your despair when, after driving across town to see your dream home, you realize it was sold. So let’s practice some self-care, shall we, and set our expectations appropriately. Step one, fill out our home buyer’s worksheet . The worksheet helps you understand what you’re looking for. Step two, with that worksheet and knowledge in hand, start browsing for homes. As you do, keep in mind exactly what that tool can, and can’t, do. Here’s how. Full Article ->
November 10, 2020
The rabid interest in West Hawaii real estate has led to a 63.41% year over year increase in the number of single family homes sold in North Kona and a 21% increase in residential sales in South Kohala according to statistics from Hawaii Information Service for October 2020. According to the Griggs Report, inventory is at the lowest level for this date since the monthly housing statistics were first reported. Pending sales are strong and lack of inventory is driving up prices. This has caused the Pending Ratio to reach a new recovery high. The current data trend shows several similarities to the peak demand years of 2003 and 2004. Median price remains up +14% and 30 day sales are at recovery peak. Prices ranges up to $1.5 million are in the peak demand category. Inventory for homes listed below $700,000 are less than 20. Median prices for single family homes in North Kona jumped 32%year over year as more homes are selling in the upper eschalon of prices due to the lack of inventory below $700,000. The median price of homes was $869,000 with condos jumping 8.32% year over year to $371,000 up from $342,500 in 2019. Condo sales have been improving and sales are up 7.5% from last year when 40 condos sold in October 2019 and 43 sold in 2020. Land sales are following the trend of the improved residential market with sharp decline in inventory with sales rising 133% year over year from 9in 2019 to 21 in 2020. This improved demand has caused prices to increase dramatically since August. This demand and price trend is similar to the peak demand year in 2004. The Griggs Report is published semi-monthly by Michael B. Griggs, PB, GRI
By Taylor Rodamer October 21, 2020
From tech tools, trends and marketing ideas to real world local case studies during the challenging days of COVID-19, here are five things you should know about the Adapt and Thrive Tech Expo: 1. The Expo is complimentary with your membership! It’s FREE. NO charge. 2. Nobu Hata, past NAR Director of Outreach, will discuss the “New Normal in RE/Tech” and trends. 3. WHAR member, Dylan Nonaka, will be a panelist sharing his experience successfully managing the pandemic on the “Adapt and Thrive” panel on October 27th at 9 am. 4. HIS will share a special preview of its fast and new powerful MLS system coming 2021. 5. Prizes! Networking! Don’t forget it is 8:00 am to 12:00 pm each day. CLICK HERE TO REGISTER
More Posts
Share by: